Categories
This blog was designed with love

Are you interested in showing your support for my site? Feel free to post a blog button!

Blueshelled.com

We are members of one great body. Nature planted in us a mutual love, and fitted us for a social life. We must consider that we were born for the good of the whole. Lucius Annaeus Seneca

Vigilante justice: Mob beats man who allegedly raped 11-year old girl

Several weeks ago, I was on twitter and noticed one from my friend, Happy Hour Sue. She’d mentioned a story about a man who’d allegedly raped an 11-year old and had been beaten by an angry mob. The vigilante justice had been given when someone recognized the man in his neighborhood, walking down his street. The crowd was not charged for the beating because of the “high level of emotion” in the community.

The video you just saw was taken before anything was confirmed about Jose Carrasquillo, the suspect in the case. Later, ABC news reported that they found surveillance camera of Jose with the 11-year old rape victim, dragging her down an alley and into a backyard where he raped her severely enough that she had to undergo surgery.

What are your thoughts on vigilante justice? In this case, investigators implied that they might not have found Carrasquillo without the help of the neighbors who chased him down. He may have gone on to hurt others. Did he deserve the beating?

I think that most parents would have done the same thing that the neighbors did. They would have chased down the guy and hurt him, then held him down until the police got there. We’ve become very reliant upon our penal system to deter crime. In this case, we took care of our own.

For the better or for the worse?

Jillian

4 Comments

  1. Leon aka Husband says:

    I think the Commissioner indicated he didn’t charge the mob because he determined they were trying to subdue the guy in order to bring him to the police, rather than trying to beat him for the sake of beating him. I’m kind of skeptical of that explanation, but if true, that makes this particular case a lot easier to call.

  2. Jillian says:

    I’m skeptical of that, as well, to be honest. However, the video is pretty unclear and if the guy is guilty, of course he’d be fighting it. Granted, if he were innocent and a mob jumped him, he’d probably be fighting it as well.

  3. Over the past few years, I’ve started blogging more and more about the justice system in the United States. While the system has its flaws, it is much better than vigilante justice. Vigilante justice is just plain wrong.

    I hope that a jury finds the truth about what happened and that the rapist gets appropriate punishment. I hope it is done within the scope of the justice system.
    Aldon @ Orient Lodge´s last blog ..Sky blue, and Sea Green – The New Normal #iranelection My ComLuv Profile

  4. Sarah says:

    Wow this is a hard one. I’d want to hurt someone who did something like this, especially if I knew the girl involved. But then I also believe that our justice system tries to ensure that people are fairly brought to justice and punished so that mobs don’t have the potential of turning criminal themselves. In this case, there’s the added factor that once in jail, this guy will suffer vigilante justice beyond anything decent civilians could have accomplished. There’s a code of honor among prisoners and child rapists often wind up dead in jail–even other hard criminals can’t stand that act.

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

About Me
Life is like a game. We all have challenges, thoughts, opinions and beliefs. Often, it feels like something out there, life, karma, catty people, or blue shells (for the Kart lovers), seeks to bring us down. Luckily, we always get up. This is where I wear my heart on my sleeve and my foot in my mouth.
Contact me

jillian@blueshelled.com
P.O. Box 252, Franklin, TN 37064

Donations

Shine


I'm a featured blogger on Mamapedia Voices

Misc


MyFreeCopyright.com Registered & Protected

Sponsors
Korres Body

I am currently accepting new sponsorships. Please email me for more information.